How to Get Group Health Insurance: A Complete Guide

For years, large corporations have had an unfair advantage, using their size to negotiate incredible rates on top-tier health insurance plans. This has left many small businesses feeling like they have to settle for less, offering subpar benefits that don't attract the best talent. But what if you could access those same Fortune 500-level benefits? That’s the power of partnering with a Professional Employer Organization (PEO). This guide will not only explain the fundamentals of how to get group health insurance but also reveal how a PEO can be your secret weapon. We’ll show you how bundling your HR and benefits can unlock better rates, simplify administration, and give your team the amazing coverage they deserve.

Key Takeaways

• Gain a Competitive Edge: Offering group health insurance is a powerful way to attract and retain top talent. It's more affordable than you might think due to group rates and significant tax deductions, making it a smart investment in your team's loyalty and your company's growth.
• You Have Several Paths to Coverage: You aren't limited to one option when searching for a plan. You can work with a traditional broker, use the SHOP marketplace, or partner with a PEO to access better plans and rates typically reserved for large companies.
• Don't Go It Alone: The world of benefits is complex, but you don't need to be an expert. Working with a professional simplifies the entire process, from comparing plans and managing enrollment to ensuring you stay compliant with all the rules.

What Is Group Health Insurance?

If you're a small business owner, the topic of health insurance can feel like a huge, complicated puzzle. But one of the most important pieces to understand is group health insurance. At its core,

The main reason this is such a popular option for businesses is that it spreads the insurance risk across the entire group of employees. For an insurance company, covering a group is less risky than covering just one person. This shared risk means the insurer can offer lower premiums, making coverage more affordable for both you and your team. Think of it like buying in bulk—you get a better price. As an employee benefits broker, we help businesses find the right group plan that balances cost and quality, ensuring your team gets the care they deserve without breaking your budget.

How It Works

The process is pretty straightforward. As the employer, you choose and purchase a group health insurance plan for your company. You’ll typically pay a significant portion of the monthly premium, and your employees cover the rest, usually through simple payroll deductions. This shared cost makes high-quality health care accessible to your team. These plans provide coverage for a wide range of medical services and must follow federal regulations like the Affordable Care Act (ACA), which sets standards for what plans must cover. This ensures your employees get comprehensive, reliable coverage they can count on.

Group Plans vs. Individual Plans

When comparing your options, you’ll see that group plans are almost always more cost-effective than individual plans. Because you’re purchasing insurance for a whole team, you have more bargaining power, which leads to lower premiums for everyone. It’s the same reason a family-size box of cereal costs less per ounce than a single-serving one. Beyond the price, group plans often provide more comprehensive benefits and a wider network of doctors compared to what an individual might find on their own. This is a key part of our cost-reduction strategies, as we leverage our expertise to secure robust plans at competitive group rates.

Does Your Business Qualify for Group Health Insurance?

Before you start comparing health plans and dreaming of amazing benefits packages, there are a few boxes you need to tick. Insurance carriers have specific rules to determine if your business qualifies for a group plan. It might sound intimidating, but it’s usually straightforward. Let’s walk through the three main requirements you’ll need to meet to get the green light.

Meeting Employee Minimums

First things first, you need to have at least one W-2 employee on your payroll who isn't an owner or their spouse. This is a firm rule for group health insurance. So, if your business is just you, or you and your spouse, you won't qualify for a group plan just yet. The employee must be a legitimate, non-owner team member receiving a W-2 tax form. This requirement ensures that the plan is for a genuine "group" and not just a way for an individual to get group rates. It’s the initial gate you have to pass through, and it’s a crucial first step in offering small business employee benefits.

Understanding Participation Requirements

Next up is what’s called the participation requirement. Most insurance carriers will ask that a certain percentage of your eligible employees—usually around 70%—actually enroll in the plan. This might sound like a high bar, but here’s the good news: employees who can show they have other health coverage don't count against you. If a team member is already covered by a spouse's plan, Medicare, or another policy, they can waive enrollment, and it won't hurt your participation numbers. This makes it much easier for small businesses to meet the threshold. A PEO broker can help you survey your team and manage this process so there are no surprises.

Calculating Your Contribution

Finally, let's talk about money. In California, insurance carriers require employers to pay at least 50% of the premium for their employees. This is for the employee's coverage only; you can decide if you want to contribute to their dependents' premiums. For example, if an employee's monthly premium is $500, your business must contribute at least $250. This rule ensures that the health plan is affordable enough for employees to actually use it. Budgeting for this contribution is a critical part of the process. Thinking through these numbers early on is one of the most effective cost-reduction strategies you can employ when setting up your benefits.

What Are the Costs of Group Health Insurance?

Okay, let's talk about the numbers. The cost of group health insurance is often the biggest question on a small business owner's mind. While it’s a significant investment, understanding the breakdown can make it feel much more manageable. The total cost is split between what you, the employer, contribute and what your employees pay. Plus, there are some great tax advantages that can lower your overall expense.

How Premiums and Contributions Work

The monthly premium is the total price of the health plan. As the employer, you'll cover a portion of this premium, and your employees will pay the rest. On average, employers contribute around $626 per month for an individual's plan and nearly $1,600 for a family plan. Your team members then cover the remaining balance through payroll deductions. Of course, these figures can change based on your location, the plan you choose, and your team’s demographics. This is where working with a PEO broker can be a game-changer, as they often have access to more competitive rates than a small business could find on its own.

What Your Employees Will Pay

Your employees' contribution is a key part of their overall compensation package. Typically, employees pay about 16% of the premium for single coverage and 25% for family coverage. For smaller businesses, that family contribution can sometimes be closer to 33% or more. Clearly communicating these costs is important for transparency and helps your team see the full value of the benefits you’re providing. Designing a plan that balances great coverage with affordable employee contributions is crucial for attracting and retaining talent. An experienced employee benefits broker can help you find that sweet spot.

Finding Tax Credits and Deductions

Here’s the good news: offering health insurance comes with significant tax benefits. The money you pay toward employee health insurance premiums is considered a business expense, which means it's fully tax-deductible. This can lower your taxable income and save you money come tax season. Even better, if you have fewer than 25 full-time employees, you might be eligible for the Small Business Health Care Tax Credit, which can cover up to 50% of the premiums you pay. These cost-reduction strategies make offering health benefits much more attainable for small businesses.

How to Get Group Health Insurance for Your Small Business

Once you’ve confirmed you qualify for group health insurance, it’s time to find the right plan. As a small business owner, you have several paths you can take to secure coverage for your team. Each option comes with its own process and benefits, so it’s helpful to understand how they differ before you start your search. From working with traditional experts to joining larger groups, here are the four main ways to get group health insurance for your small business.

Work with a Traditional Broker

One of the most common routes is to work with a licensed insurance agent or employee benefits broker. Think of a broker as your guide to the insurance market. Their job is to understand your business's needs, budget, and employee demographics, and then find plans that are a good match. They can provide valuable assistance by explaining the complexities of different policies, comparing quotes from various carriers, and helping you with the application process. A good broker saves you the time and effort of researching countless plans on your own and can help you find a policy that fits your specific needs.

Explore the SHOP Marketplace

The Small Business Health Options Program (SHOP) Marketplace is a federal program designed specifically for small businesses, typically those with one to 50 employees. It offers a way to browse, compare, and purchase health insurance plans from different providers in one place. One of the key advantages of using the SHOP Marketplace is that you may qualify for the Small Business Health Care Tax Credit, which can help make coverage more affordable. The platform allows you to offer one plan or let your employees choose from several options, giving you flexibility in how you structure your benefits.

Partner with a PEO

Partnering with a Professional Employer Organization (PEO) is an effective way for small businesses to gain access to high-quality, affordable health insurance. A PEO handles various HR functions for your business, including payroll, compliance, and benefits administration. By co-employing your staff, a PEO pools employees from many small businesses into one large group. This gives you access to the same caliber of health insurance plans typically reserved for large corporations, often with more comprehensive coverage and lower premiums. A PEO broker can help you find the right PEO that bundles these essential services and simplifies your benefits management.

Join an Association Health Plan

Another option is to join an association health plan (AHP). These plans allow small businesses within the same industry or trade group to band together to purchase health insurance. By pooling their resources, members can share costs and gain the buying power of a larger group, similar to how a PEO works but focused solely on insurance. If you belong to a professional or trade organization, it’s worth checking if they offer an AHP. This can be a viable way to access more affordable group coverage, especially for businesses in niche industries that have strong member associations.

What to Look For in a Group Health Plan

Once you start comparing group health plans, you’ll notice they’re not all created equal. It’s easy to get lost in a sea of acronyms and percentages, but finding the right fit for your team comes down to a few key areas. Think of it less like shopping for a utility and more like choosing a partner for your company’s well-being. The cheapest plan isn’t always the best one, especially if it doesn’t meet your employees' needs or creates administrative headaches for you down the line. Offering health insurance is a major decision for your business, and it deserves careful thought about the costs and benefits for everyone involved.

To make a smart choice, you need to look beyond the monthly premium. You’ll want to dig into what the plan actually covers, which doctors and hospitals your team can visit, and how much support you’ll get with the day-to-day management. A great plan strikes a balance between comprehensive coverage that your employees will value and a cost that your business can sustain. It should also make your life easier, not harder, by simplifying enrollment and compliance. Below, we’ll break down the three most important things to evaluate when you’re weighing your options, so you can feel confident in your final decision.

Reviewing Coverage and Benefits

The monthly premium is just the starting point. To understand the true cost for your employees, you need to look at the details of the coverage. This includes the deductible (what they pay before the plan kicks in), copayments (a flat fee for a doctor’s visit), and the out-of-pocket maximum—the most an employee will pay in a year. A plan with a low premium might have a high deductible, which could be a tough pill to swallow for an employee facing an unexpected medical issue. Think about what health services the plan covers. Does it include essentials like prescription drugs, mental health support, and preventative care? Offering a plan that truly supports your team’s health shows you value them as people, not just as workers.

Checking Provider Networks and Plan Types

A health plan is only as good as the doctors and hospitals it includes. Before you commit, you need to understand the plan’s network and the different types of health insurance plans available. The two most common are HMOs and PPOs. HMOs (Health Maintenance Organizations) often have lower premiums but require members to use doctors within their network and get a referral to see a specialist. PPOs (Preferred Provider Organizations) offer more flexibility to see both in-network and out-of-network doctors without a referral, but the costs are usually higher. Make sure the plan’s network includes reputable providers in your area so your team doesn’t have to switch doctors. You can usually check a plan’s provider directory online before signing up.

Evaluating Admin and Compliance Support

Offering health insurance comes with a lot of administrative work, from enrolling new hires to answering questions and staying compliant with regulations like the Affordable Care Act (ACA). Some plans leave you to handle all of this on your own, which can quickly become a major time sink. When evaluating your options, ask about the level of administrative support included. A great employee benefits broker or PEO won’t just sell you a plan; they’ll help you manage it. This support is vital for ensuring you meet all your legal requirements and can focus on running your business, not becoming a benefits expert overnight.

How to Implement Your New Health Plan

Once you’ve chosen a group health plan, it’s time to put it into action. This implementation phase involves a few key steps, from submitting your official application to getting your team enrolled and making sure your payroll is set up correctly. It can feel like a lot of moving parts, but breaking it down makes it much more manageable. Getting this stage right is crucial for a smooth rollout and ensures your employees can start using their new benefits without a hitch.

The Application and Approval Process

First things first, you’ll need to formally apply to the insurance carrier. This involves submitting a detailed application with information about your business and your employees. The insurer will review everything to confirm your eligibility and finalize your rates. You can typically purchase group health insurance through the Small Business Health Options Program (SHOP) marketplace or directly from private insurance companies. The paperwork and underwriting process can be time-consuming, which is why many business owners work with a broker to handle the details. An expert can guide you through the entire PEO selection process, ensuring your application is accurate and submitted correctly to avoid delays.

Enrolling and Communicating with Your Team

With your plan approved, the next step is to get your employees enrolled. Most insurance carriers require a certain percentage of eligible employees—often around 70%—to participate in the plan. Clear communication is key here. You’ll need to explain the plan options, costs, and benefits so your team can make informed decisions. Many modern platforms offer digital enrollment, making it easy for employees to sign up online or through an app. As your employee benefits broker, we can help you prepare enrollment materials and even host informational sessions to answer your team’s questions, ensuring a smooth and successful open enrollment period.

Setting Up Payroll and Staying Compliant

The final piece of the puzzle is integrating the new health plan with your payroll system. You’ll need to set up pre-tax deductions for your employees' share of the premiums. Remember, the amount your business pays toward health insurance premiums is generally a tax-deductible business expense, which is a great financial perk. It’s also critical to stay on top of compliance requirements, like those under the Affordable Care Act (ACA). A PEO can be invaluable here, as they manage payroll deductions, tax filings, and compliance reporting for you. This not only saves you time but also provides peace of mind, letting you focus on your business while knowing your cost-reduction strategies are sound.

Why Offer Group Health Insurance?

Deciding to offer health insurance can feel like a huge step, especially when you’re carefully managing your budget. But it’s one of the most powerful investments you can make in your business. Think of it less as an expense and more as a strategic tool for growth. Providing health benefits sends a clear message that you value your team’s well-being, which can transform your company culture and set you apart from competitors. It’s a foundational piece of a compensation package that helps you build a resilient, loyal, and motivated workforce.

While the process might seem complicated, the advantages are significant. You gain a competitive edge in the hiring market, unlock access to more affordable insurance rates, and can even lower your business’s tax bill. The key is understanding how to make it work for your specific situation. With the right guidance from an employee benefits broker, you can find a plan that fits your budget and meets your team’s needs. Let’s walk through the main reasons why offering group health insurance is a smart move for your small business. It's about more than just checking a box; it's about creating a workplace where people feel secure and supported, allowing them to do their best work. This investment pays dividends in productivity, morale, and your ability to attract the best people in your industry.

Attract and Keep Top Talent

In a competitive job market, salary is only part of the equation. A quality health insurance plan is often the deciding factor for a candidate choosing between two job offers. It shows you’re invested in your employees' long-term health and security, which builds loyalty and reduces costly turnover. Offering health insurance is a major choice for your business, and you should think carefully about the cost and what the plan covers. When you provide meaningful benefits, you create a supportive environment where people feel valued and are more likely to stay and grow with your company.

Save Money with Group Rates

One of the biggest advantages of group health insurance is its affordability. Group plans are typically much cheaper than individual plans because the insurer’s risk is spread across multiple people. Insurers negotiate lower rates for groups, giving you access to pricing that’s usually reserved for larger companies. This collective bargaining power means you can offer excellent coverage without breaking the bank. This is one of the most effective cost-reduction strategies a small business can use to provide high-value benefits while managing expenses. You get to offer a top-tier perk that supports your team and your bottom line.

Enjoy Tax Breaks and Guaranteed Coverage

The financial incentives don't stop with group rates. The government encourages small businesses to offer health insurance through significant tax advantages. The money you contribute toward your employees' health insurance premiums is generally considered a tax-deductible business expense, which can lower your overall tax liability. Furthermore, if you have fewer than 25 full-time employees, you may be eligible for the Small Business Health Care Tax Credit, which can cover up to 50% of the premiums you pay. These tax breaks make offering health insurance much more financially manageable.

Common Challenges for Small Businesses

Offering health insurance can feel like a major hurdle, especially when you're juggling a dozen other business priorities. Many small business owners get stuck on the same few challenges: the perceived cost, the complexity, and some common myths that just aren't true. Let's clear the air so you can move forward with confidence.

Clearing Up Common Misconceptions

It’s easy to assume that a bigger paycheck is all that matters to your team, but that’s rarely the case. While salary is important, employees consistently rank health insurance as one of their most valued workplace benefits. Offering a solid plan can be the deciding factor that makes a top candidate choose your company over another, and it plays a huge role in keeping your current team happy and loyal. Another common myth is that group health insurance is a rigid, one-size-fits-all solution. The reality is that there are many small business employee benefits available that can be tailored to your specific needs and budget, so you don't have to settle for a generic plan.

Managing High Costs and Tight Budgets

The number one concern for most small businesses is, without a doubt, the cost. It's true that health insurance is a significant investment, but it's often more affordable than you think. The key is to avoid going it alone. Working with an experienced benefits consultant can help you find custom options that fit your budget without sacrificing the quality of coverage your employees receive. They can introduce you to creative cost-reduction strategies, such as self-funded or level-funded plans, which can offer significant savings by giving you more control over plan design. Plus, offering a group plan can lead to tax savings for both you and your employees, making the overall cost much more manageable.

Handling Complex Rules and Requirements

Between state mandates, federal laws, and insurance carrier paperwork, the world of group health insurance can feel incredibly complicated. This complexity alone is enough to deter many business owners from even starting the process. They worry about making a mistake, missing a deadline, or choosing the wrong plan and being stuck with it. This hesitation is understandable, but it can prevent you from finding a great, affordable solution for your team. The good news is you don't have to become an expert in benefits administration overnight. Following a clear process with a trusted partner can simplify everything, allowing you to focus on what you do best—running your business.

How a PEO Simplifies Group Health Insurance

If you’ve ever felt like offering great health insurance is out of reach for your small business, you’re not alone. Juggling costs, complex regulations, and administrative tasks can feel overwhelming. This is where partnering with a Professional Employer Organization (PEO) can be a total game-changer. A PEO essentially lets you join forces with other small businesses to gain the benefits and bargaining power of a large enterprise, all without the associated headaches.

Think of a PEO as an extension of your team that handles the heavy lifting of HR and benefits. Instead of you spending hours comparing plans and managing paperwork, the PEO does it for you. They take on the administrative burden of benefits, payroll, and compliance, bundling everything into one streamlined service. This partnership not only saves you time and money but also gives your employees access to top-tier health plans they’ll love. By working with a PEO broker, you can find the right partner to manage these complexities, allowing you to focus on what you do best: running your business. It’s a strategic way to offer competitive benefits that attract and retain great talent.

Get Better Rates and Coverage

One of the biggest advantages of using a PEO is gaining access to better health insurance at a lower cost. PEOs achieve this through a simple principle: strength in numbers. They pool the employees from all their small business clients into one large group, sometimes numbering in the thousands. This gives them significant leverage when negotiating with insurance carriers, much like a Fortune 500 company. As a result, you can offer your team high-quality, comprehensive health plans that are typically only available to large corporations. These cost-reduction strategies mean you no longer have to settle for subpar plans with high deductibles just to stay within budget. You get better coverage for a better price.

Bundle HR and Compliance Support

Navigating the world of benefits compliance can feel like trying to read a map in a foreign language. Rules surrounding the Affordable Care Act (ACA), COBRA, and other regulations are complex and constantly changing. A single misstep can lead to hefty fines and legal trouble. A PEO removes this risk by providing a dedicated team of compliance experts. They manage all the necessary reporting, ensure your plans meet legal requirements, and keep you updated on any legislative changes that affect your business. This bundled support gives you peace of mind, knowing that a professional employee benefits broker is handling the details so you can avoid costly mistakes and stay focused on your team.

Simplify Administration and Setup

Beyond securing great plans, there’s the day-to-day work of managing them. Onboarding new employees, handling open enrollment, processing claims, and answering endless questions can quickly consume your schedule. A PEO simplifies all of this by integrating benefits administration directly with your payroll and HR functions on a single, easy-to-use platform. This means no more manual data entry or juggling multiple systems. Your employees get a straightforward portal to manage their benefits, and you get a dedicated support team to handle the administrative tasks. Our process ensures a smooth transition, freeing you from the paperwork and giving you back valuable time to invest in growing your business.

Find the Right Health Insurance Solution

Choosing a health insurance plan is a significant decision, but it doesn't have to be a stressful one. With a clear understanding of your options and a solid process, you can find a solution that fits your team and your budget perfectly. The key is to move forward methodically, starting with your company’s unique needs and then exploring the market to see what’s available. This final stage is all about bringing your research together to make an informed choice that will serve your business well for years to come. It’s tempting to jump straight to getting quotes, but without a clear strategy, you can easily get lost in a sea of confusing options and industry jargon.

Think of it as a simple, three-step process. First, you'll look inward to define what you and your employees truly need from a health plan. What kind of coverage is essential? What does your budget look like? Second, you'll look outward to compare the different plans and providers available to you. This is where you’ll weigh the pros and cons of various networks, benefit structures, and costs. Finally, you’ll bring in an expert to help you make sense of it all. Finding the right small business employee benefits is much easier when you have a clear plan and the right support to guide you.

Assess Your Needs and Budget

Before you start looking at plans, take some time to figure out what you’re looking for. Offering health insurance is a major choice, so you’ll want to think carefully about the cost for both your business and your employees, as well as what health services the plan covers. Start by asking what your team values most. Do they need robust family coverage, mental health support, or low deductibles? Once you have a handle on your team’s needs, you can establish a realistic budget. Decide how much the company can contribute to monthly premiums and what you expect employees to pay. This internal assessment will give you a clear benchmark to measure potential plans against.

Compare Your Options and Providers

With your needs and budget defined, you can start comparing what’s out there. You’ll find a variety of plan types, from HMOs to PPOs, each with different provider networks and out-of-pocket costs. Group health insurance is often more affordable than individual plans, but the quotes can still vary widely between insurance carriers. As you review your options, look beyond the monthly premium. Consider the deductibles, copays, and coinsurance to understand the total potential cost for your employees. This is the stage where many business owners feel overwhelmed by the details, but taking the time to compare different options ensures you find a plan that offers real value.

Get Expert Guidance

You don’t have to sort through all the complexities of health insurance on your own. In fact, it’s highly recommended to work with a knowledgeable, licensed professional who can guide you through the process. An experienced employee benefits broker can help you find the best coverage, understand the rules, and negotiate rates on your behalf. They do the heavy lifting of sourcing quotes and comparing the fine print, saving you countless hours of research. A trusted partner can translate the jargon, answer your team’s questions, and ensure you’re making a confident, well-informed decision that aligns perfectly with your business goals.

Related Articles

• Group Health Insurance for Small Business: A 2025 Guide
• Your Guide to a Small Business Benefits Broker

Frequently Asked Questions

What if some of my employees don't want the insurance because they're covered by a spouse? This is a very common situation and, thankfully, it won't prevent you from qualifying for a plan. Insurance carriers look for a certain percentage of your eligible employees to enroll, but anyone who can show they have other valid coverage (like through a partner's job or Medicare) can waive enrollment. These waivers don't count against you, making it much easier for your business to meet the participation requirement.

Is partnering with a PEO the only way to get affordable health insurance? Not at all, but it is a uniquely powerful option. You can certainly work with a traditional insurance broker to find a great plan. The key difference is that a PEO bundles health insurance with other essential services like payroll, compliance, and HR support. By pooling employees from many small businesses, PEOs gain access to the kind of high-quality plans and competitive rates that are usually reserved for large corporations, simplifying your administrative load in the process.

How much time will I really have to spend managing this plan once it's set up? If you go it alone, managing a health plan can become a significant time commitment, involving everything from enrolling new hires to answering questions and ensuring you're compliant with regulations. This is precisely the problem that working with a PEO or a dedicated benefits broker solves. They take on the administrative heavy lifting so you can get back to focusing on what you do best—running your business.

My business is very small, with just a handful of employees. Is group health insurance even a realistic option? Yes, absolutely. Group health insurance is designed for businesses of all sizes, and you typically only need one W-2 employee (who isn't an owner or their spouse) to qualify. Options like PEOs are specifically structured to help small companies access the same benefits as much larger ones, making great coverage both achievable and affordable even for the smallest teams.

What's the difference between the monthly premium and what my employees will actually pay for care? Think of the monthly premium as the fixed membership fee for the health plan, which is usually split between you and your employee. The out-of-pocket costs, like deductibles and copayments, are what your employee pays when they actually use their insurance for a doctor's visit or a medical procedure. A great plan finds the right balance between an affordable monthly premium and reasonable out-of-pocket costs so there are no surprises.